The Buddha at Kamakura
"And there is a Japanese idol at Kamakura"
O ye who tread the Narrow Way
By Tophet-flare to Judgment Day,
Be gentle when the 'heathen' pray
To Buddha at Kamakura!
To him the Way, the Law, apart,
Whom Maya held beneath her heart,
Ananda's Lord, the Bodhisat,
The Buddha of Kamakura.
For though he neither burns nor sees,
Nor hears ye thank your Deities,
Ye have not sinned with such as these,
His children at Kamakura.
Yet spare us still the Western joke
When joss-sticks turn to scented smoke
The little sins of little folk
That worship at Kamakura --
The grey-robed, gay-sashed butterflies
That flit beneath the Master's eyes.
He is beyond the Mysteries
But loves them at Kamakura.
And whoso will, from Pride released,
Contemning neither creed nor priest,
May feel the Soul of all the East
About him at Kamakura.
Yea, every tale Ananda heard,
Of birth as fish or beast or bird,
While yet in lives the Master stirred,
The warm wind brings Kamakura.
Till drowsy eyelids seem to see
A-flower 'neath her golden htee
The Shwe-Dagon flare easterly
From Burmah to Kamakura,
And down the loaded air there comes
The thunder of Thibetan drums,
And droned -- "Om mane padme hums" --
A world's-width from Kamakura.
Yet Brahmans rule Benares still,
Buddh-Gaya's ruins pit the hill,
And beef-fed zealots threaten ill
To Buddha and Kamakura.
A tourist-show, a legend told,
A rusting bulk of bronze and gold,
So much, and scarce so much, ye hold
The meaning of Kamakura?
But when the morning prayer is prayed,
Think, ere ye pass to strife and trade,
Is God in human image made
No nearer than Kamakura?
Commentary
1892.
I don’t know if Kipling ever made the trip to Kamakura to gaze upon the Great Buddha, but his poem upon the subject remains, in my opinion, one of the most perfect evocations ever of ‘the Soul of all the East’. Indeed, I can hardly read it without hearing Tibetan drums and scenting joss sticks and seeing saffron-clad monks going about their morning prayers…
It’s a profoundly religious poem, but no less universal or accessible for that; in fact, I would call it, rather, a wonderful exaltation of humanism and a call for gentleness and understanding. The philosophy may not be ‘deep’, but it’s certainly very moving.
‘The Buddha at Kamakura’ should also serve as a rebuttal to those who continue to view Kipling as a heavy-handed imperialist, a relic of bygone colonial days. It’s true he sings the praises of the British Empire (more specifically, of the soldiers and scribes who built that Empire), but he is also more tolerant, more honourable, and above all, more universal than many of his contemporaries and latter-day critics. And he had a rare gift of words - his verse, whether the Cockney slang of Tommy Atkins or the pulsing rhythms of the Jungle Book or the archaic patternings of today’s poem, is always vibrant and alive, and it sticks in the memory.
On a personal note: I made the pilgrimage to the Daibutsu (the Great Buddha) at Kamakura last weekend, and I must say it’s a truly awe-inspiring spectacle. For one thing, it’s big - it towers over the hordes of tourists that infest the place. And it’s incredibly, incredibly beautiful - the expression on the Buddha’s face is serene, calm, compassionate, wise… ineffable. The statue is in the open (the wooden structure that housed it was washed away in a tsunami, many hundreds of years ago) (which in itself is a sobering thought), and it sits in quiet repose through wind and rain, sun and shade. Sitting zazen in the temple grounds really brought the power of today’s poem home to me.
— Thomas
[History Lesson]
Kamakura was the capital of Japan in the 13th and 14th centuries. It was chosen because it was easy to defend, with densely-wooded hills on three sides and the sea on the fourth. The first Shogun of the Kamakura period, Yoritomo Minamoto, died and both of his sons were assassinated; power then passed to the Hojo clan (to which one of his wives belonged). The construction of the Great Buddha was started at the behest of this wife; it was completed around 1250. The statue itself is hollow and made of bronze; it’s 44 feet high and perfectly proportioned. In addition to the Daibutsu, Kamakura has literally dozens of small shrines and temples; in that sense, it’s like a smaller version of Japan’s other ancient capital, Kyoto.
The Kamakura period ended in 1333, when the Emperor’s troops successfully laid seige to it. No less than 800 warriors of the Hojo and allied clans committed seppuku (ritual suicide) in the precincts of the Engakuji temple. Yes, Japan had a very bloody feudal history.
[Tidbit #1]
‘The Voyage of Captain John Saris to Japan, 1613’ includes the following passage:
The Countrey betwixt Surnunga [ed. ‘Suruga’, a province of Japan] and Edoo [ed. ‘Edo’, the old name for Tokyo] is well inhabited. We saw many Fotoquise [ed ‘Hotoke-san’?, translates to ‘Our Lord Buddha’] or Temples as we passed, and amongst others one Image of especiall note, called Dabis [ed. ‘Daibutsu’, or ‘Great Buddha’], made of Copper, being hollow within, but of very substantiall thicknesse. It was in height, as wee ghessed, from the ground about one and twentie or two and twentie foot, in the likeness of a man kneeling upon the ground, with his buttockes resting on his heeles [ed. This is not accurate], his arms of wondefull largeness, and the whole body proportionable. He is fashioned wearing of a Gowne. This Image is much reverenced by Travellers as they passe there.
– filched from the Web, http://www-swiss.ai.mit.edu/~bentz/buddha.html
[Tidbit #2]
NOTICE
KOTOKU-IN MONASTERY
KAMAKURA
Stranger, whosoever thou art and whatsoever be thy creed, when thou enterest this sanctuary remember thou treadest upon ground hallowed by the worship of ages. This is the Temple of the Buddha and the Gate of the Eternal, and should therefore be entered with reverence.
BY ORDER OF THE PRIOR.
Notes
The Narrow Way is a reference to Christianity; contrast the ‘Eight-fold Path’ of Buddhism and the ‘Middle Way’ of Confucianism. Tophet is, I presume, a place, but I don’t know where. Maya was Gautama’s mother. Ananda is the faithful chela (disciple) who features in many tales of the Buddha. A Bodhisat (Bodhisattva) is a soul who reaches enlightenment and then devotes his/her life to helping others do the same. ‘htee’ is not a typo; it’s in italics in the original. I don’t know what it refers to (as always, pointers appreciated). The Shwe-Dagon pagoda is in Burma. ‘Om mane padme hum’ is a meditation chant. Brahmans are the hereditary Hindu priestly caste. Benaras is the holy city of Varanasi, at the junction of the Ganges and the Yamuna. Buddh-gaya is the spot at which Gautama attained enlightenment and became the Buddha.
Show 8 commentsHide comments
From the Wondering Minstrels mailing list, 1999–2008.
nolan_mark_e · 25 October 2000
Tophet is a place in a valley SW of Jerusalem. Not sure exactly what is derived from what, but it is also the name of the shrine of Moloch (on that spot) where parents sacrificed their children. Also a generic name for a place of child sacrifice or the burial of sacrificial victims (as in Carthage).
gmason · 14 March 2002
This is for “The Buddha at Kamakura” by Rudyard Kipling.:
Kipling was criticised by the establishment of the Empire at the time of his writing for being too close to the native and too close to the native’s aspirations. Now he is criticised for being right-wing and imperialistic.
When both sides criticise, I think you have it right.
The poem evokes respect, not merely for the statue, but for Buddhism. It captures the thoughts and answers them of anyone who sees the Buddha at Kamakura. It was true then and true now.
The typical Kipling verse form addresses all emotion and all the cultures surrounding the viewing of the Buddha and at just the right level. Intended, possibly, as a guide for the behaviour of British Soldiers of the Raj when in the vicinity of Buddhist Shrines anywhere, its gentle language and honest advice, turn slowly to a forceful appreciation of, and respect for, a symbol and a belief.
A brilliant poem, scattered with allusions and strong with rhythm, yet wise and humble.
Kipling was a brilliant writer - and here, on his subject of The East, he could not be better.
Kipling used selected verses from the poem to introduce the first 3 chapters of “Kim”.
Edward Little · 2 September 2002
Many thanks for explanatory comments to this great poem which has many references not familiar to the western mind. And for the accurate appreciations of Kipling, a great poet and a great man. Any one who reads Kim must see that he loved India and Eastern cultures. Likewise this poem.
For Tophet there is a good (brief) reference in the Columbia Encyclopedia , at least in the 1950 ed.). The Shwe-Dagon is a great temple in Burma. What are the “joss sticks” that “turn to scented smoke?” Ritual, of course, but - ?
BEm004176B Adcrafters · 11 February 2003
Thanks for all the help with this great poem of Kipling’s. My bit of knowledge is that a “joss” is a 19th-c British slang word for a “heathen” god, and a joss-stick is incense, obviously burned in honor of that god.
Any idea on how to pronounce “htee” and “Shwe-Dagon”? And are the “butterflies” the monks?
Thanks again,
Diana
Jeffrey McNabb · 2 April 2003
i journeyed to Kamakura in 1962 at 11 yrs old; in awe of the wonder of Amitabha, I scarcely new what the Buddha world meant; I returned to Kamakura in 1980 on a trip back from India; now a buddhist, I realized ‘what’ I saw as an 11yr old boy;
Honor, justice, compassion, kindness - the code of my life forever more.
Thank you
Jeffrey McNabb
John van V · 27 July 2005
Kipling had a weird concept, the middle path of European conciousness.
He called it the “White Man’s Burden”
He was a hell of a poet !!
Edward Cherlin · 9 August 2005
The “butterflies” are indeed the priests, wearing Chinese style robes (koromo), with sleeves a yard wide and long that do sometimes look like wings. Over the koromo they wear the kesa, the colored robe of the precepts that they have taken as their life’s training. The kesa leaves the right shoulder uncovered–thus “sashes”.
I have not been to Kamakura, but I trained in Japanese monasteries.
Kay and Phil Cogswell · 7 May 2007
One usage of “Tophet,” according to my old Webster’s New International Dictionary (2nd ed.), was as a literary allusion to Hell, I assume because of the terrible nature of the Old Testament place where children were sacrificed. So I think the first verse is properly construed as being addressed to the English Christian who walks the narrow way between Hell’s fires (“Tophet-flare”) and Judgement Day. My visit to the the Kamakura Buddha was totally due to this poem. As a young Navy officer in 1965, I and some colleagues were taking the train from the Navy base at Yokuska to Tokyo when I noticed we were passing into Kamakura. All I knew was that Kipling had written about a Buddha there and so I persuaded my friends to get off the train and look for it. Immediately I was worried that maybe there would be no Buddha any more or that it would be hard to find, but as it turned out there was a sign at the station “to the Buddha” and the statue was only a short walk away. More than 40 years later, it remains one of the most memorable works I have ever seen, both the statue itself and the sense of of history and veneration that the site projected. Phil