Rain

Naomi Shihab Nye

 A teacher asked Paul
 what he would remember
 from third grade, and he sat
 a long time before writing
 "this year somebody tutched me
 on the sholder"
 and turned his paper in.
 Later she showed it to me
 as an example of her wasted life.
 The words he wrote were large
 as houses in a landscape.
 He wanted to go inside them
 and live, he could fill in
 the windows of "o" and "d"
 and be safe while outside
 birds building nests in drainpipes
 knew nothing of the coming rain.

Commentary

I don’t know much about the poetic merits of this modern piece. But what I do know is that Naomi takes a stereotype, turns it upside down and shows what strange waters can flow from the most unexpected of places if you can see them. I have always known that a dunce is not so a dunce if you don’t look for them. So many of these so-called “dunces” were some of the best friends I had, guys who would gang up & beat seniors who ragged me while “intellectuals” watched in fear. Whenever teachers slapped these “dunces”, I would always want to scream at them, but I had to quietly satisfy myself with splashing ink on their clean shirts and sarees when they weren’t looking. That was once upon a time, but I still fill the windows of my “o”s and “d”s and don’t even leave out the tiny half-moon of “e” ;-)

— Nelson

Biography

http://voices.cla.umn.edu/authors/NYEnaomishihab.html


The Wondering Minstrels, poem #1379 · 4 November 2003

Guest poem submitted by Nelson JS Santhosh

Fair use