On the Birth of his Son

Su Shi (Su Dongpo)

 Families, when a child is born
 Want it to be intelligent.
 I, through intelligence,
 Having wrecked my whole life,
 Only hope the baby will prove
 Ignorant and stupid.
 Then he will crown a tranquil life
 By becoming a Cabinet Minister.

Commentary

A universal gem in sarcasm…

         [ CE)
         translated by Arthur Waley (1919)

The Confucian examination system for recruiting officials into the bureaucracy may have been far more egalitarian than anything comparable in its heyday; yet it had its limits. Wealthy men were able to hire tutors to ensure their success, and poor but intelligent men seldom rose to the top.

Su Tung-p’o, usually considered the greatest poet of the Sung Dynasty, often commented cynically on the system he considered corrupt and was dismissed from various positions for his pains. His sarcasm in the following poem sounds a strikingly contemporary note in this age of cynicism about politicians. The poet’s revenge lies in the fact that his poems are still read and memorized when all those who persecuted him have been forgotten.

— Raj

Martin adds

There’s a wonderful takeoff on the examination system in Pratchett’s “Interesting Times”, though that poked fun not at its fairness, but at its utility in selecting capable people. I’m also reminded of the President in Roald Dahl’s “Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator”:

    It soon began to dawn on me
    He wasn't very bright
    Because when he was twenty-three
    He couldn't read or write
    'What shall we do?' his parents sob
    'The boy has got the vapors!
    He couldn't even get a job
    Delivering the papers!'
    'Ah-ha!' I said, 'this little clot
    Could be a politician.'
    'Nanny', he cried 'Oh, Nanny, what
    A super proposition!'

Any resemblance to actual presidents is strictly coincidence (and mighty prophetic coincidence at that). Great book, for those of you who’ve never encountered Dahl.

— Martin


The Wondering Minstrels, poem #1217 · 6 April 2003

Guest poem submitted by Rajarshi Bandyopadhyay

Fair use

Show 2 commentsHide comments

From the Wondering Minstrels mailing list, 1999–2008.

Martin DeMello · 6 April 2003

There are also, of course, G&S, and the “Ruler of the Queen’s Navy” from Pinafore. Oddly, I can’t seem to find the lyrics on line; I have them in text form, of course, but I’m lazy.

I don’t think that’s quite the same - he may have “never thought of thinking for himself at all”, but the song was more about the landboundedness of his career than about his stupidity or incompetence. Even the judge from “Trial by Jury” wasn’t portrayed as quite as inept as the targets of today’s poem.

martin

Alan Kornheiser · 6 April 2003

There are also, of course, G&S, and the “Ruler of the Queen’s Navy” from Pinafore. Oddly, I can’t seem to find the lyrics on line; I have them in text form, of course, but I’m lazy.